Wednesday, March 11, 2009

The Truth of the Memoir

I'm no philosopher, asking what the nature of Truth is.

I'm no scientist, proving what the Truth is through tests and experiments.

I'm a writer. I follow my own intuitions about a piece. This is my first creative nonfiction class, but I've written memoirs before this, and I've kept a frequent journal these past few years, and infrequently before that. I'm beginning to feel like I'm growing up to be more like my mother than I had realized. I can almost hear myself: "Just do it and be done with it!" Say what you want, how you remember it.

What I wanted during class on Tuesday was nothing more than to crawl out the window. The discussion got deeper and deeper, became more twisted, more complex, and I kept cursing myself for choosing a chair that had my back to the window. There would have been some interesting window-staring happening had I chosen a different seat.

See, Truth is relative to many things. When did the memory occur? If I was five years old, I'll notice and remember different things than if something similar happens years later. A parent or friend who was with me would remember something different. My mother told me once that one day when I was in kindergarten, my teacher, Mrs. Bailey, told our class that we would have our very first fire drill. Despite being warned, when the alarms went off, eighteen five and six year olds dissolved into tears.

I have no memory of this.

How did Mrs. Bailey finally get those eighteen students lined up and out of the classroom? Classes were usually that size in my school, but how do I know there were that many of us? Why was my mother there on that day, or how did she know about it? Does she remember that? And why is it important, anyway?

When remembering a situation that happened even a few weeks ago, I might wonder if the setting was different, it it really was him or her who spoke with me, what he or she said and did. The only constant about the human memory is that it is inconsistent. It can turn colors different shades, from one face or voice to another, even something as significant as the setting.

That being said, my philosophy is to use your head. If you can't remember how you or someone else reacted to something, imagine what you or they would have done, knowing the both of you. As long as the conversation takes place, what does it matter where it takes place?

Keats's famous saying is quoted in a song "Give Them What They Want" from the musical Dirty Rotten Scoundrels. It's the song I've had playing in my head since I started writing this piece. Truth is Beauty. But sometimes Truth remains elusive, and always will. No one will remember the same scene the same way. No one will remember a scene in the way it was, just the cold facts, without bias. That isn't human nature. We're all self-interested creatures. There's no way to deny that or take a step back until the scene has already happened.

So while I understand the theoretical discussions and the philosophy behind the subject, I would rather go out into the world and get into a scenario myself instead of just talking about it. The time we spent in class is a perfect example: half of us were engaged in a battle of words, perceiving the conversation to be important, their answers to be their own Truth; and myself, watching the clock, impatiently cursing my back to the window.

3 comments:

  1. So do you think that there is any benefit in comparing notes with someone else who was there (especially if you were very young at the time)? Or is it more important to write about your own memory of certain events, regardless of if there are conflicting accounts? What if there are gaps in your memory? Would it then be acceptable to have someone else who was there help you fill them in? Or is that a form of fabrication because it is not truly an accurate portrayal of your memory?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Illuminating. From the blogs I've read, it seems that many students were a tad antsy during the discussion on truth. You appear to prefer an instinctual, more figurative probing of the past than an attempt to torture total honesty out of it. I like that.

    Now if only our brains were better stenographers. Then again, would this genre be a paltry husk without a little controlled tampering to season the story?

    ReplyDelete
  3. i really like how you use a story from when you were so young in this entry, it helps illustrate your point and it is also something at everyone can relate too.

    ReplyDelete